Home / Middletown / Second Hand Store
Second Hand Store in Middletown
65 second hand store businesses in Middletown, United States. All Middletown businesses →
At a glance
As of August 2026, business.wiki lists 65 second hand store businesses in Middletown— 0.5% of the city's 12,911 listed businesses. 92% publish a phone number and 74% have a website, spread across 52 postcode districts. The largest local presence is Goodwill with 6 locations in the city.
Where in Middletown: 06457 (7)·10940 (4)·06457-2941 (2)·07748-2025 (2)·21769-7722 (2)·95461 (2)·02842-5610 (1)·06457-1819 (1)
Directory — top 30 by data completeness
| Business | Address | Postcode | Phone | Web |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Treasures of the Chest | 1380 Central Ave | 45044-4132 | +15137271475 | ✓ |
| Reboot Eco Swap Studio | 131 River Rd | 06457-3917 | +18603223366 | ✓ |
| United Presbyterian Thrift Shop | 25 Orchard St | 10940 | +18453432131 | ✓ |
| Goodwill | 115 Urton Ln | 40223-3943 | +15024898344 | ✓ |
| The Salvation Army | 4440 Marie Dr | 45044-9085 | +18007287825 | ✓ |
| Goodwill Retail Store & Donation Center | 805 E Main St | 21769-7722 | +12406518994 | ✓ |
| Goodwill | 801 N Broad St | 19709-1148 | +13023766258 | ✓ |
| Plato's Closet | 1421 State Route 35 | 07748-2030 | +17328659412 | ✓ |
| Bishop's Auto Parts | 120 Stantack Rd | 06457-2308 | +18603462336 | ✓ |
| Newfield Street Exchange | 1397 Newfield St | 06457-1819 | +18606356666 | ✓ |
| Goodwill Middletown | 955 Washington St | 06457-2941 | +18603475404 | ✓ |
| Irreplaceable Artifacts | 428 Main St | 06457-3366 | +18603448576 | ✓ |
| Middletown Peddler's Mall | 12405 Shelbyville Rd | 40243-1418 | +15022457705 | ✓ |
| Red Barn Antique & Art Emporium | 12125 Old Shelbyville Rd | 40243-1437 | +15022458330 | ✓ |
| Middletown Antiques Collective | 24524 Bradford Rd | 95461-9784 | +17072953172 | ✓ |
| United Methodist Women's Thrift Shop | 21216 Washington St | 95461 | +17079879743 | ✓ |
| Conley Trading Co | 100 E Main St | 19709-1428 | +13025595738 | ✓ |
| The Whistle Stop | 114 Sleepy Hollow Dr | 19709-8894 | +13023780123 | ✓ |
| Calico Cat Thrift Shoppe | 96 Kings Hwy | 07748-2025 | +17326710550 | ✓ |
| Any Old Thing | 4 W Main St | 10940-5778 | +18459787259 | ✓ |
| Lovely Ladies Consignment Shop | 280 RT-211 E | 10940-3100 | +18453435277 | ✓ |
| Your Closet or Mine | 541 Washington St | 06457-2512 | +18603473300 | ✓ |
| Never Say Goodbye | 808 Washington St | 06457 | (860) 704-0807 | ✓ |
| Alva's Attic | 134 Aquidneck Ave | 02842-5610 | +14016842963 | ✓ |
| Goodwill Industries International, Inc. | 955 Washington St | 06457 | +18004663945 | ✓ |
| Middletown flea market indoor | 470 Route 211 E | 10940-2246 | +18455494126 | ✓ |
| Why Not Antiques | 7994 Main St | 22645-9541 | +15408681141 | ✓ |
| Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center | 237 Wickham Ave | 10940 | (800) 728-7825 | ✓ |
| Serendipity Consignments | 2885 State Route 17K | 10941-4308 | +18453613509 | ✓ |
| Forest City Merchants | 10 Cooley Ave | 06457-3805 | +18608523050 | ✓ |
Showing the 30 most complete records of 65 total. Every listed business has its own page with map, nearby competitors and city context.
About this data
Counts are computed live from our database of 12,911 Middletown businesses, built on open data from the Overture Maps Foundation and refreshed with each monthly release. Cite as: “business.wiki, Second Hand Store in Middletown (August 2026)”.