Home / Key West / Casual Eatery
Casual Eatery in Key West
80 casual eatery businesses in Key West, United States. All Key West businesses →
At a glance
As of August 2026, business.wiki lists 80 casual eatery businesses in Key West— 2% of the city's 4,017 listed businesses. 98% publish a phone number and 85% have a website, spread across 53 postcode districts. The largest local presence is Mattheessen's with 3 locations in the city.
Where in Key West: 33040 (24)·33040-6506 (3)·33040-4248 (2)·33040-6518 (2)·33040-3113 (1)·33040-3114 (1)·33040-3127 (1)·33040-3141 (1)
Chains here: Mattheessen's ×3·Cakes by Karol ×2·Croissants de France ×2·Häagen-Dazs ×2·Subway ×2
Directory — top 30 by data completeness
| Business | Address | Postcode | Phone | Web |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subway | 817 17th St | 33040-4248 | +13052950081 | ✓ |
| Tavern N Town | 3841 N Roosevelt Blvd | 33040 | +13052968100 | ✓ |
| Subway | 542 Truman Ave | 33040-3141 | +13052921397 | ✓ |
| Kermit's Key Lime Pie | 802 Duval St | 33040 | (800) 376-0806 | ✓ |
| Dolphin Deli | 5600 Maloney Ave | 33040-5983 | +13052930707 | ✓ |
| Waffle House | 3852 N Roosevelt Blvd | 33040 | (305) 293-9132 | ✓ |
| Miami Subs | 1800 N Roosevelt Blvd | 33040-3631 | +13052940001 | ✓ |
| Jersey Mike's | 2798 N Roosevelt Blvd | 33040-3904 | +13052044815 | ✓ |
| Flamingo Crossing Ice Cream | 1105 Duval St | 33040-3127 | +13052966124 | ✓ |
| Santiago's Bodega | 207 Petronia St | 33040-7305 | +13052967691 | ✓ |
| Little Whitehouse Subs | 218 Whitehead St | 33040-6595 | +13053041470 | ✓ |
| Häagen-Dazs | 425 Front St | 33040-6661 | +17865893465 | ✓ |
| River Street Sweets | 400 Duval St | 33040-7669 | +13059222144 | ✓ |
| Häagen-Dazs | 625 Duval St | 33040-6554 | +13054536218 | ✓ |
| Harpoon Harry's | 832 Caroline St | 33040-6656 | +13052948744 | ✓ |
| Old Town Bakery | 930 Eaton St | 33040-6957 | +13053967450 | ✓ |
| Key West Cakes | 1014 White St | 33040-3387 | +13052964162 | ✓ |
| Southern Most Deli | 1330 Simonton St | 33040-3114 | +13052931352 | ✓ |
| Wicked Lick Ice Cream | 335 Duval St | 33040-6579 | +13053996687 | ✓ |
| Croissants de France | 5620 MacDonald Ave | 33040 | +13059165669 | ✓ |
| Key West Polar Bear Ice Cream Parlor | 247 Front St | 33040 | +13052939966 | ✓ |
| Glazed Donuts | 420 Eaton St | 33040-6512 | +13052949142 | ✓ |
| Key Lime Pie Bakery | 412 Greene St | 33040-6518 | +13052969515 | ✓ |
| Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge | 505 Duval St | 33040-6552 | +13053200986 | ✓ |
| Key West Key Lime Pie Co. | 511 Greene St | 33040-6632 | +13055176720 | ✓ |
| Mattheessen's | 419 Duval St | 33040-8332 | +13059235418 | ✓ |
| Court House Deli Bench | 600 Whitehead St | 33040-8303 | +13052942929 | ✓ |
| Abbey Road Snack Shack | 3675 S Roosevelt Blvd | 33040-5254 | +13059230715 | ✓ |
| Better Than Sex | 926 Simonton St | 33040-7448 | +13052968102 | ✓ |
| 5 Brothers Key West | 930 Southard St | 33040-7176 | +13052965205 | ✓ |
Showing the 30 most complete records of 80 total. Every listed business has its own page with map, nearby competitors and city context.
About this data
Counts are computed live from our database of 4,017 Key West businesses, built on open data from the Overture Maps Foundation and refreshed with each monthly release. Cite as: “business.wiki, Casual Eatery in Key West (August 2026)”.